Disembodied hand coming out of a stack of bitters gift-set boxes, stirring a mixing pitcher full of cocktail, in a festive scene with books, bitters, drinks, candles, pumpkins, and various statues. Disembodied hand coming out of a stack of bitters gift-set boxes, stirring a mixing pitcher full of cocktail, in a festive scene with books, bitters, drinks, candles, pumpkins, and various statues.

Make Cocktail Magic

Shop Bitters

Premium Cocktail Bitters made in NYC by NYC mixologists.

Handcrafted with the Finest Organic Ingredients for Creating Inspired Cocktails.

Fall Favorites

View all
Sale
A bottle of Spicy Scorpion Bitters by Bennett Bitters.
The back label of a bottle of Spicy Scorpion Bitters by Bennett Bitters.
Scorpion Bitters
$22.00 from $17.60 Save $4.40
Sale
A bottle of Old Fashioned Cocktail Bitters by Bennett Bitters.
The back label of a bottle of Old Fashioned Cocktail Bitters by Bennett Bitters.
Cocktail Bitters
$22.00 $17.60 Save $4.40
Sale
A bottle of Aromatic Exorcism Bitters by Bennett Bitters.
The back label of a bottle of Aromatic Exorcism Bitters by Bennett Bitters.
Exorcism Bitters
$22.00 $17.60 Save $4.40
View all
3 products

Shop by cocktail

Hands making old fashioned cocktail, next to pumpkins.
Old Fashioned / Manhattan
Margarita cocktail on a slate board with other margaritas.
Margarita / Mojito
Two tropical orange colored cocktails, with cocktail shaker, mangos, and a pineapple.
Piña Colada / Mai Tai
Martini cocktail and a flower on a napkin, sitting on a bartop.
Martini / Collins

Fall Cocktail Recipes

Bad Blood

Strawberry Gin Sour

Gin, Strawberry Hibiscus Tea, Lemon Juice, Bermuda Bitters, Cocktail Bitters

Summon the Recipe

Tricky Treat

Peach Whisky Punch

Single Malt Scotch, Lillet, Peach Liqueur, Peach Black Tea, Wild Hunt Bitters

Summon The Recipe

Silencio

Mezcal Margarita

Mezcal, Lemon, Cointreau, Agave, Scorpion Bitters, Mesquite Smoked Chili Salt

Summon the Recipe
Hand dripping bitters into an orange colored cocktail with ice.

What exactly are bitters?

Out of mixologists' secret stash and into your home bar, bitters are the mystery ingredient no bar can live without.

Discover the Secret
The three bottles in The Esoteric Collection; Exorcism Bitters, Scorpion Bitters, and Wild Hunt Bitters by Bennett Bitters.
The Esoteric Collection; Exorcism Bitters, Scorpion Bitters, and Wild Hunt Bitters by Bennett Bitters, booklets and box.
The Esoteric Collection by Bennett Bitters bottles laying down and surrounded by rosemary and white pumpkins.
The Esoteric Collection by Bennett Bitters bottles arranged on a tree stump with green foliage in the background.
The Esoteric Collection by Bennett Biiters bottles surrounded by tarot cards, lavender, and herbs.
The three bottles in The Esoteric Collection; Exorcism Bitters, Scorpion Bitters, and Wild Hunt Bitters by Bennett Bitters.
The Esoteric Collection; Exorcism Bitters, Scorpion Bitters, and Wild Hunt Bitters by Bennett Bitters, booklets and box.
The Esoteric Collection by Bennett Bitters bottles laying down and surrounded by rosemary and white pumpkins.
The Esoteric Collection by Bennett Bitters bottles arranged on a tree stump with green foliage in the background.
The Esoteric Collection by Bennett Biiters bottles surrounded by tarot cards, lavender, and herbs.

Esoteric Collection

$58.00 $46.40 Save $11.60
/

Featuring three of our Organic, Hand-crafted flavor stories, the Esoteric Collection Premium Bitters Set is the perfect gift for yourself or a fellow lover of cocktails, mocktails, and adventurous drinks.

Spicy Scorpion, Aromatic Exorcism, Herbal Wild Hunt Bitters 

Whether you’re a seasoned drink maker or you’re new to mixology, The Esoteric Collection will inspire the senses and your recipes. 

Type

About Our Brand

Organic

Made with 100% Organic alcohol and Organic botanicals.

Sustainable

We are dedicated to sustainability in every step of our production and shipping.

Handmade

Small batch and lovingly hand-made with the highest standards in New York City.

LEARN MORE
Mixologist made

Next Level Cocktail Ingredients

New York City mixologists Yana and Joey channeled the standards of the world's most famous cocktail scene to create Bennett Bitters.

Hand-Crafted with the finest organic ingredients under herbalist supervision; Bennett Bitters were made to inspire bartenders, and home bartenders alike, to create drinks that are otherworldly and nostalgic, that transport through taste.

There's a story in every bottle.

Read Our Story
Portrait of Yana and Joey, owners of Bennett Bitters.